So what’s the right impact driver for you? Forget about label on box. Sure, you think, “I have a Makita tool, so I guess it’ll get the job done.” But which specific tool get the job done?
How does it perform when you pick it up? It come down to two tools that occupy opposite ends of the spectrum in terms of size, performance, and feel. The older XDT16 is a compact beast that has paid its dues on dozens of job sites.
And then there’s the new kid on the block, the DTD171 with its promise of speed and moddern engineering. At first glance, they’re nearly identical. Same size batteries (both are 18 volts), though XDT16 is incredibly short while the DTD171 is slightly longer.
They look similar from afar. Quite different in use, however. Knowing where each stand can save you a lot of heartache when it comes time to buy a tool that doesn’t try to fight your flow.
Key Differences Between Makita Impact Drivers
Speed and Drive Performance
The first thing you’ll notice when pulling the trigger is its speed. Compared to XDT16, the DTD171 turns faster. That increased speed translate into a bite in the wood that’s a bit more aggressive.
When you’re driving longer screws into solid framing lumber, that speed make a difference; you don’t need to push as hard or as steady on the tool. It do some of the initial work for you. Again, only a little bit of an advantage, but it does add up over time on a hundred fastener.
Torque and Heavy Duty Power
The XDT16 is still plenty fast enough for most applications, it just isn’t quite as fast-moving. Many folks just aren’t concerned about top speed as much as they are torque delivery. The XDT16 has a well-deserved reputation for raw power.
It’s a sledgehammer in a small package. This can comes in quite handy when penetrating hardwood or driving structural bolt. While the DTD171 certainly deliver enough torque, the XDT16 has earned a reputation of being unstoppable.
For those who build heavy decks or frame houses for a living, that additional punch gets them going. You wouldn’t of want something that’s gonna stall out.
Size, Balance and Ergonomics
Fatigue is also influenced heavily by size and balance.
The XDT16 is incredibly short and compact, allowing it to get into very small areas such as corners of cabinets or underneath floors (crawl space). This is what make this tool most advantageous. The DTD171 is slightly longer and heavier.
It’s balance point changes from the other tool too and some people like that because it give them more leverage where they need it, while others liked the quick reaction time to pressure with shorter tool. Much of that comes down to application. If you’re working over your head, weight matter much more.
If you’re working at waist level, the weight doesn’t matter nearly as much.
Battery Compatibility and Durability
Makita realy stands out when it comes to battery compatibility. The exact same LXT battery system power both tools.
You’ll be able to move batteries from your driver to your saw to your drill without batting an eye. And that’s really one of the reasons folks stay loyal to Makita. Because as you grow your tool collection, you also collect a bunch of batteries that power them all.
Power source isn’t typically a factor when deciding between these two drivers. It comes down to what’s inside the housing, the motor. No one want a wimpy pro tool.
These two were designed to be durable. They will live in the mud, get kicked around and dropped off a ladder. The XDT16 has been through the wringer for years and is proven.
The DTD171 is new but they shares the same rugged DNA. Makita doesn’t skimp on the casing. Both tools feel solid.
The chucks hold bit firmly in place and the trigger is responsive. No need to baby these tool.
Choosing the Right Tool for Your Job
Ultimately it’s up to you.
The DTD171 is an awesome tool if you’re doing drywall or softwood work where speed is very important. It is quick, it is easy. The XDT16 remains the champion on the heavy duty stuff where you want to get it done right now, or if you like a smaller tool to fit in tight places.
They’re both different tools for slightly different tasks but neither is wrong. Choose what fits you and where you’ll be working.